Insider Compass
An expert assessment built on data, context and gastronomic judgement.
About New York Burger, Pso Castellana 89
On the bustling Paseo de la Castellana, New York Burger has been delivering proper American-style burgers since 2009, built around a defining detail: every patty gets kissed by coal-fired heat that imparts a genuine char and smokiness you don't find in your typical griddle operation. Chef Pablo Colmenares, trained at Le Cordon Bleu and battle-tested in the innovative kitchens of DiverXO, brings unexpected technical rigor to comfort food. The result is a spot that satisfies burger cravings with serious attention to craft, complete with thoughtful vegan and vegetarian options that don't feel like afterthoughts.
Good to know
Order the Chelsea Truffle or Queens Burger if you want to see the kitchen's range—both showcase how coal-fired cooking and thoughtful toppings can elevate familiar formats.
The chef
Pablo Colmenares
Pablo Colmenares brings an unexpected pedigree to the burger game, having trained at Le Cordon Bleu before cutting his teeth in the avant-garde kitchens of DiverXO, where precision and creativity are non-negotiable. That foundation shows in his approach at New York Burger: coal-fired cooking isn't just a gimmick but a considered technique that extracts maximum flavor and texture from quality proteins. His philosophy centers on honoring American comfort food traditions while applying the discipline and craft he honed in fine dining, resulting in burgers that taste indulgent but never sloppy. Colmenares also champions inclusivity on the menu, ensuring vegan and vegetarian diners experience the same care and flavor development as omnivores.
The Insider Compass
Four dimensions, each assessed independently against the same criteria everywhere we rate.
Plate
The coal-fired oven is the hero here, delivering that elusive Maillard reaction and genuine smoke penetration that makes every burger taste like it came off a backyard grill at its absolute peak. Patties arrive juicy and well-seasoned, with toppings that show restraint—pulled pork, truffle accents, and chicken parm variations all demonstrate kitchen confidence beyond the standard cheese-and-bacon playbook. Don't overlook the Asian-style wings or the brisket tacos; there's real technique in those starters that hint at Colmenares' fine-dining background.
Vibe
LivelyThe space leans into rustic Americana with warm yellow tones and a laid-back energy that shifts depending on the crowd—quiet early evenings can turn lively when the place fills up, especially during NFL game broadcasts that draw enthusiastic groups. Expect a casual, no-fuss atmosphere where families, couples, and solo diners all find their comfort zone. Arrive off-peak if you want breathing room; prime dinner hours and game days mean waits and a buzz that some love, others find overwhelming.
Service
The front-of-house team—regulars mention Felipe, Diego, and Daniel by name—brings genuine warmth and attentiveness that elevates the experience beyond typical casual dining. Staff are accommodating with dietary requests and cooking preferences, though language barriers can occasionally slow communication for non-Spanish speakers. When the dining room is slammed, pacing can lag, but the hospitality intent is clear and consistent.
Setting
Located at a high-visibility corner of Paseo de la Castellana, the restaurant offers easy access in Madrid's Tetuán district, though the interior trades scenic views for that classic American diner aesthetic—think exposed brick tones, straightforward seating, and a focus on function over flair. The space is clean and well-maintained, designed to let the food take center stage rather than compete with elaborate décor. On slower nights, the AC can take a minute to catch up, so dress accordingly if you're visiting in warmer months.
These four dimensions are a handful of the attributes we review. The Insider Rating also draws on research the compass does not display — among them the wine programme, the size and quality of the cellar, the location, and how long the house has operated. It is not an average of the scores above.
Go for
- Coal-fired burgers with genuine smoke and char that taste like they came off a live-fire grill
- Vegan and vegetarian options crafted with the same care as the meat-centric menu
- Casual, welcoming service in a no-pretense environment perfect for families or relaxed gatherings
Don't go for
- Quick turnover during peak dinner or NFL game nights when waits and kitchen pacing can stretch
- Fine-dining ambiance or a curated wine program—this is comfort food done well, not haute cuisine
Details
P.º de la Castellana, 89, Tetuán, 28046 Madrid, Spain
$$