Insider Compass
An expert assessment built on data, context and gastronomic judgement.
RECOGNITIONS
About El Romero
Tucked into a historic building opposite the Santa María de Mahón church, El Romero is Menorca's most convincing case for sustainable fine dining done with real soul. The kitchen, led by self-taught chef Fabio Tullini and his wife, sommelier and maître Francesca Baroni, builds four tasting menus entirely around what local farmers and fishermen bring to the door each morning — with everything on the menu 100% gluten-free by design, not afterthought. It's a rare address where ethos and execution align: Menorca Biosphere Reserve certified, FoodMadeGood two-star rated, and holding a Repsol Sol. Ideal for travelers who want elevated Menorcan-Italian cooking without sacrificing dietary needs or conscience.
Good to know
Book ahead — tables are limited and word has spread among gluten-free and celiac travelers seeking a genuinely safe fine-dining option.
The chef
Fabio Tullini
Fabio Tullini's path to the kitchen is unconventional: he spent over two decades as a legal, tax, and accounting consultant before following a growing passion for wine and food into a second career. Earning his sommelier title sharpened his palate and gastronomic instincts long before he ever ran a kitchen, and that self-taught, sensory-first approach still defines his cooking today. Alongside his wife Francesca Baroni, who runs the dining room and wine program, Tullini built El Romero around radical local sourcing and sustainability rather than classical technique for its own sake. His philosophy favors letting Menorcan ingredients speak clearly, refined through Italian sensibility rather than heavy intervention.
The Insider Compass
Four dimensions, each assessed independently against the same criteria everywhere we rate.
Plate
The kitchen works in a light, precise Italian-Menorcan register, letting the day's catch and the huerta's vegetables do most of the talking rather than heavy sauces or over-manipulation. Dishes like the prawn tartare, scallops with white chocolate, and scorpion fish showcase genuine technique and a willingness to take small risks with texture and pairing. Seasoning can occasionally read as too restrained for palates used to bolder Mediterranean flavor, but the sourcing integrity is consistently evident on the plate.
Vibe
LivelyThe room reads as contemporary and composed rather than rustic, with an initial hush that softens once the wine starts flowing and the amuse-bouche arrives. It suits couples and food-focused travelers seeking conversation-friendly quiet over buzzy energy. The terrace on Plaça de la Conquesta adds a relaxed, people-watching layer for warmer evenings.
Service
Service is warm, multilingual, and genuinely knowledgeable — expect staff who can speak fluently about sourcing, allergens, and the wine list without missing a beat. Francesca Baroni's presence as maître and sommelier gives the room a personal, hosted feel rather than a formal, distant one. Pacing is generally attentive, though a full tasting menu naturally unfolds at a deliberate, unhurried rhythm.
Setting
Set in a historic Mahón building facing the Santa María church, the space pairs old stone bones with a clean, modern interior that feels more gallery than trattoria. The outdoor tables on Plaça de la Conquesta offer one of the more atmospheric alfresco settings in town. It's intimate rather than expansive, favoring quality of experience over scale.
These four dimensions are a handful of the attributes we review. The Insider Rating also draws on research the compass does not display — among them the wine programme, the size and quality of the cellar, the location, and how long the house has operated. It is not an average of the scores above.
Go for
- A genuinely celiac-safe, 100% gluten-free tasting menu experience
- A sustainability-driven, farm-to-table and sea-to-table philosophy executed with real technique
- An exceptional, thoughtfully curated natural and biodynamic wine list
Don't go for
- A loud, high-energy night out — the atmosphere leans quiet and refined
- Bold, heavily seasoned traditional Spanish cooking — the style is more delicate and Italian-inflected
Details
Plaça de la Conquesta, 5, 07701 Maó, Illes Balears, Spain
$$$$