Call Me Gaby
Miami Beach, United States · South Beach
Insider Compass
An expert assessment built on data, context and gastronomic judgement.
About Call Me Gaby
Call Me Gaby brings a charming slice of Italy to Miami Beach's Washington Avenue with its feminine European decor and enchanting atmosphere. This Italian restaurant has carved out a niche since 2017 with its specialty Pinsa Romana pizza and fresh pasta dishes, creating an inviting space with outdoor seating adorned with flowers and greenery, plus intimate upstairs dining areas and balcony nooks.
While the restaurant delivers solid Italian fare with standout dishes like the pear pasta and various pinsa offerings, it operates as a neighborhood favorite rather than a culinary destination. The dog-friendly patio and lively atmosphere make it particularly appealing for casual dining, though some service inconsistencies and mixed experiences suggest room for improvement in execution.
Good to know
Request a table on the charming outdoor patio with flowers and greenery for the best atmosphere, especially during lunch on nice days
The chef
Not available
Chef information not provided in available data.
The Insider Compass
Four dimensions, each assessed independently against the same criteria everywhere we rate.
Plate
Call Me Gaby's kitchen focuses on Italian comfort food with their signature Pinsa Romana as the star attraction. This Roman-style pizza offers a lighter, more digestible alternative to traditional Neapolitan pizza. Reviewers consistently praise the freshness of ingredients and highlight dishes like the pear pasta and watermelon salad as standouts.
While guests describe the food as "delicious" and "amazing," the praise tends toward enthusiasm rather than culinary sophistication. The seafood preparations receive positive mentions, and the pasta dishes earn particular acclaim from visitors. However, the overall execution appears to be solid neighborhood Italian rather than elevated cuisine, with quality that satisfies but doesn't necessarily surprise or innovate.
Vibe
LivelyService at Call Me Gaby receives generally positive feedback, with many reviewers praising the staff's attentiveness and recommendations. Guests frequently mention following server suggestions successfully, and the overall hospitality appears warm and accommodating, particularly regarding the restaurant's dog-friendly policy.
However, some operational inconsistencies surface in reviews, including confusion with reservations and seating arrangements, with one guest noting disappointment about table placement despite booking specific seating. While most experiences are positive, these service hiccups suggest room for improvement in consistency and attention to guest expectations.
Service
Setting
Located on Washington Avenue in Miami Beach, Call Me Gaby occupies a prime spot that allows for the expansive outdoor dining that defines much of its appeal. The multi-level layout with outdoor patios, upstairs dining areas, and balcony nooks creates intimate spaces within a larger restaurant footprint.
The feminine European decor with colorful touches and abundant greenery creates a distinctive aesthetic that sets it apart from typical Miami Beach dining. The outdoor spaces, adorned with flowers and plants, provide an almost garden-like escape from the urban street setting, though the restaurant doesn't offer exceptional views or historic architecture - rather, it creates its own charming microenvironment through thoughtful design and landscaping.
These four dimensions are a handful of the attributes we review. The Insider Rating also draws on research the compass does not display — among them the wine programme, the size and quality of the cellar, the location, and how long the house has operated. It is not an average of the scores above.
Go for
- Casual Italian dining with charming outdoor ambiance
- Pinsa Romana pizza and fresh pasta dishes
- Dog-friendly patio dining in Miami Beach
Don't go for
- Fine dining or culinary innovation
- Quiet, intimate conversation
Details
22 Washington Ave, Miami Beach, FL 33139, USA
$$